Loading...

Q&A with AFSA on the State of Alternative Data

Published: July 18, 2018 by Kerry Rivera

As more financial institutions express interest and leverage alternative credit data sources to decision and assess consumers, lenders want to be assured of how they can best utilize this data source and maintain compliance.

Experian recently interviewed Philip Bohi, Vice President for Compliance Education for the American Financial Services Association (AFSA), to learn more about his perspective on this topic, as well as to gain insights on what lenders should consider as they dive into the world of alternative credit data.

Alternative data continues to be a hot topic in the financial services space. How have you seen it evolve over the past few years?

It’s hard to pinpoint where it began, but it has been interesting to observe how technology firms and people have changed our perceptions of the value and use of data in recent years. Earlier, a company’s data was just the information needed to conduct business. It seems like people are waking up to the realization that their business data can be useful internally, as well as to others.  And we have come to understand how previously disregarded data can be profoundly valuable. These insights provide a lot of new opportunities, but also new questions.  I would also say that the scope of alternative credit data use has changed.  A few years ago, alternative credit data was a tool to largely address the thin- and no-file consumer. More recently, we’ve seen it can provide a lift across the credit spectrum.

We recently conducted a survey with lenders and 23% of respondents cited “complying with laws and regulations” as the top barrier to utilizing alternative data. Why do you think this is the case? What are the top concerns you hear from lenders as it relates to compliance on this topic?

The consumer finance industry is very focused on compliance, because failure to maintain compliance can kill a business, either directly through fines and expenses, or through reputation damage. Concerns about alternative data come from a lack of familiarity. There is uncertainty about acquiring the data, using the data, safeguarding the data, selling the data, etc. Companies want to feel confident that they know where the limits are in creating, acquiring, using, storing and selling data.

Alternative data is a broad term. When it comes to utilizing it for making a credit decision, what types of alternative data can actually be used?

 Currently the scope is somewhat limited. I would describe the alternative data elements as being analogous to traditional credit data. Alternative data includes rent payments, utility payments, cell phone payments, bank deposits, and similar records. These provide important insights into whether a given consumer is keeping up with financial obligations. And most importantly, we are seeing that the particular types of obligations reflected in alternative data reflect the spending habits of people whose traditional credit files are thin or non-existent.  This is a good thing, as alternative data captures consumers who are paying their bills consistently earlier than traditional data does. Serving those customers is a great opportunity.

If a lender wants to begin utilizing alternative credit data, what must they know from a compliance standpoint?

I would begin with considering what the lender’s goal is and letting that guide how it will explore using alternative data. For some companies, accessing credit scores that include some degree of alternative data along with traditional data elements is enough. Just doing that provides a good business benefit without introducing a lot of additional risk as compared to using traditional credit score information. If the company wants to start leveraging its own customer data for its own purposes, or making it available to third parties, that becomes complex very quickly.  A company can find itself subject to all the regulatory burdens of a credit-reporting agency very quickly. In any case, the entire lifecycle of the data has to be considered, along with how the data will be protected when the data is “at rest,” “in use,” or “in transit.” Alternative data used for credit assessment should additionally be FCRA-compliant.

How do you see alternative credit data evolving in the future?

I cannot predict where it will go, but the unfettered potential is dizzying. Think about how DNA-based genealogy has taken off, telling folks they have family members they did not know and providing information to solve old crimes. I think we need to carefully balance personal privacy and prudent uses of customer data. There is also another issue with wide-ranging uses of new data. I contend it takes time to discern whether an element of data is accurately predictive.  Consider for a moment a person’s utility bills. If electricity usage in a household goes down when the bills in the neighborhood are going up, what does that tell us? Does it mean the family is under some financial strain and using the air conditioning less? Or does it tell us they had solar panels installed? Or they’ve been on vacation?  Figuring out what a particular piece of data means about someone’s circumstances can be difficult.

About Philip Bohi

Philip joined  AFSA in 2017 as Vice President, Compliance Education. He is responsible for providing strategic direction and leadership for the Association’s compliance activities, including AFSA University, and is the staff liaison to the Operations and Regulatory Compliance Committee and Technology Task Forces. He brings significant consumer finance legal and compliance experience to AFSA, having served as in-house counsel at Toyota Motor Credit Corporation and Fannie Mae. At those companies, Philip worked closely with compliance staff supporting technology projects, legislative tracking, and vendor management. His private practice included work on manufactured housing, residential mortgage compliance, and consumer finance matters at McGlinchey Stafford, PLLC and Lotstein Buckman, LLP. He is a member of the Virginia State Bar and the District of Columbia Bar.

Learn more about the array of alternative credit data sources available to financial institutions.

Related Posts

Discover how data analytics in utilities helps energy providers navigate regulatory, economic, and operational challenges. Learn how utility analytics and advanced analytics solutions from Experian can optimize operations and enhance customer engagement.

Published: March 10, 2025 by Stefani Wendel

To authenticate identities and combat fraud within the Gen Z population, financial organizations need to implement comprehensive strategies.

Published: August 16, 2024 by Alex Lvoff

The morning kicked off with the buzz of innovation. Shri Santhanam, Financial Services and Data General Managers Platforms and Software, and leaders from Experian debuted the latest enhancements for the Experian Ascend Technology PlatformTM. The demo touted faster automation, seamless data integration, security and compliance, and simplified experience. Resiliency, security and gen AI capabilities are all core components and outputs of the new platform. Keynote speakers: Steffi Graf and Andre AgassiTennis icons Steffi Graf and Andre Agassi captivated the audience with stories of their memorable matches, how they met and their foray into pickleball. From notorious rivals to the pivotal moments that were part of their weeks at seeding in the number 1 position – 377 weeks and 101 weeks respectively. Keynote speaker: Jason SudeikisEmmy-award winning actor, comedian, writer and producer – and also known as the affable Ted Lasso – Jason Sudeikis had the crowd laughing reminiscing his favorite skits from his time at Saturday Night Live and outtakes from his numerous films. He talked about the impact of Ted Lasso and the origin of the “Believe” sign, as well as what’s ahead. Sessions – Day 2 highlights The conference hall was buzzing with conversations, discussions and thought leadership. Some themes definitely rose to the top — the increasing proliferation of fraud and how to combat it without diminishing the customer experience, leveraging AI and transformative technology in decisioning and how Experian is pioneering the GenAI era in finance and technology. Alternative dataAlternative data can be used to holistically measure a consumer's creditworthiness. Property data to banking insights to consumer-permissioned data and more can be a critical part of your strategies to segment, analyze and underwrite unbanked and new-to-credit consumers. EngagementEconomic headwinds and fierce competition in the banking industry have acquisition costs soaring, making it more important than ever to be critical of your organization’s advertising spend. Meanwhile, consumers are trending back toward the convenience of banking bundles, and they expect their financial institutions to help them improve their financial health. These conditions create a unique opportunity to extract value from digital experiences. CollectionsData, advanced analytics and machine learning are transforming all aspects of collections during a time when consumer debt pressure is building. Organizations can harness the power of data-driven insights, predictive modeling, enhanced segmentation and optimized decisions to ensure they have the strongest contact data and best collections strategy to reduce delinquencies and boost recovery rates. See you next year for Vision 2025!

Updated : June 5, 2024 Published: May 23, 2024 by Stefani Wendel

Subscribe to our blog

Enter your name and email for the latest updates.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

Subscribe to our Experian Insights blog

Don't miss out on the latest industry trends and insights!
Subscribe