Loading...

Fluidity and extinction of fraud behavior: How to corner the rats

Published: June 10, 2010 by Guest Contributor

We’ve blogged about fraud alerts, fraud analytics, fraud models and fraud best practices.

Sometimes,though,we delude ourselves into thinking that fraud prevention strategies we put into place today will be equally effective over time. Unfortunately, when a rat finds a dead-end in a previously-learned maze, it just keeps hunting for an exit. Fraudsters are no different. Ideally we want to seal off all the exits, and teach the rats to go and do something productive with their lives, but sadly that is not always the case. We also don’t want to let too many good consumers get stuck either, so we cannot get too trigger-happy with our fraud best practices.

Fraud behavior is dynamic, not static. Fraudsters learn and adapt to the feedback they receive through trial and error. That means when you plug a hole in your system today, there will be an increased push to seek out other holes tomorrow. This underscores the importance of keeping a close eye on your fraudsters’ behavior trends.

But there must be some theoretical breaking point where the fraudsters simply give up trying–at least with your company. This behavioral extinction may be idealistic in the general sense, but is nonetheless a worthy goal as related to your business. One of the best things you can do to prevent fraud is to gain a reputation amongst the fraudsters of, “Don’t even try, it’s not even worth it.” And even if you don’t succeed in getting them to stop trying altogether, it’s still satisfying to know you are lowering their ROI while improving yours

Related Posts

Fraud rings cause an estimated $5 trillion in financial damages every year, making them one of the most dangerous threats facing today’s businesses. They’re organized, sophisticated and only growing more powerful with the advent of Generative AI (GenAI). Armed with advanced tools and an array of tried-and-true attack strategies, fraud rings have perfected the art of flying under the radar and circumventing traditional fraud detection tools. Their ability to adapt and innovate means they can identify and exploit vulnerabilities in businesses' fraud stacks; if you don’t know how fraud rings work and the right signs to look for, you may not be able to catch a fraud ring attack until it’s too late. What is a fraud ring? A fraud ring is an organized group of cybercriminals who collaborate to execute large-scale, coordinated attacks on one or more targets. These highly sophisticated groups leverage advanced techniques and technologies to breach fraud defenses and exploit vulnerabilities. In the past, they were primarily humans working scripts at scale; but with GenAI they’re increasingly mobilizing highly sophisticated bots as part of (or the entirety of) the attack. Fraud ring attacks are rarely isolated incidents. Typically, these groups will target the same victim multiple times, leveraging insights gained from previous attack attempts to refine and enhance their strategies. This iterative approach enables them to adapt to new controls and increase their impact with each subsequent attack. The impacts of fraud ring attacks far exceed those of an individual fraudster, incurring significant financial losses, interrupting operations and compromising sensitive data. Understanding the keys to spotting fraud rings is crucial for crafting effective defenses to stop them. Uncovering fraud rings There’s no single tell-tale sign of a fraud ring. These groups are too agile and adaptive to be defined by one trait. However, all fraud rings — whether it be an identity fraud ring, coordinated scam effort, or large-scale ATO fraud scheme — share common traits that produce warning signs of imminent attacks. First and foremost, fraud rings are focused on efficiency. They work quickly, aiming to cause as much damage as possible. If the fraud ring’s goal is to open fraudulent accounts, you won’t see a fraud ring member taking their time to input stolen data on an application; instead, they’ll likely copy and paste data from a spreadsheet or rely on fraud bots to execute the task. Typically, the larger the fraud ring attack, the more complex it is. The biggest fraud rings leverage a variety of tools and strategies to keep fraud teams on their heels and bypass traditional fraud defenses. Fraud rings often test strategies before launching a full-scale attack. This can look like a small “probe” preceding a larger attack, or a mass drop-off after fraudsters have gathered the information they needed from their testing phase. Fraud ring detection with behavioral analytics Behavioral analytics in fraud detection uncovers third-party fraud, from large-scale fraud ring operations and sophisticated bot attacks to individualized scams. By analyzing user behavior, organizations can effectively detect and mitigate these threats. With behavioral analytics, businesses have a new layer of fraud ring detection that doesn’t exist elsewhere in their fraud stack. At a crowd level, behavioral analytics reveals spikes in risky behavior, including fraud ring testing probes, that may indicate a forthcoming fraud ring attack, but would typically be hidden by sheer volume or disregarded as normal traffic. Behavioral analytics also identifies the high-efficiency techniques that fraud rings use, including copy/paste or “chunking” behaviors, or the use of advanced fraud bots designed to mimic human behavior. Learn more about our behavioral analytics solutions and their fraud ring detection capabilities. Learn more

Published: February 27, 2025 by Presten Swenson

Fraud never sleeps, and neither do the experts working to stop it. That’s why we’re thrilled to introduce Meet the Maker, our new video series spotlighting the brilliant minds behind Experian’s cutting-edge fraud solutions. In our first episode, Matt Ehrlich, Senior Director of Identity and Fraud Product Management, and Andrea Nighswander, Senior Director of Global Solution Strategy, share how they use data, advanced analytics, and deep industry expertise to stay ahead of fraudsters. With 35+ years of combined experience, these fraud-fighting veterans know exactly what it takes to keep bad actors at bay. Watch now for an exclusive look at the minds shaping the future of fraud prevention.    Stay tuned for more episodes featuring the visionaries driving fraud innovation.

Published: February 21, 2025 by Julie Lee

Romance scams target individuals of all ages and backgrounds. Financial institutions need to protect their customers from these schemes.

Published: February 5, 2025 by Alex Lvoff